Oscars 2025: The Oscars took place last Sunday, and I have to admit that the results were more than a little surprising. I had felt overall that the films generally for 2024 for these awards were not a strong as in previous years. I don’t think, despite the results, there was no clear cut Best Picture. For me, as a theatrical release, I think that the Best Picture to see in the theatres would be Dune Part II, as a visual spectacle it was stunning. As a story, I think that Conclave was more compelling in width and breadth, and in terms of gravity of a story that Nickel Boys was the most substantial. One could argue that The Brutalist also was an Oscar-worthy movie overall, for me I found it too long, with the second half weaker than the first. Anora I suspect was viewed by most on a television screen or smaller monitor. But as a story, it was quite pedestrian.

From Kieran Culkin to Mikey Madison, Wicked for Cinematography and others I was feeling that the Academy missed the mark, in a Shakepeare in Love over Saving Private Ryan kind of way from 1999. My brother, who won my Oscar Pool for the third time in a row summed it up well after his win with “Voting for and giving away awards to movies hardly anyone has seen, and no one will care about in the future”. I have been losing faith in the Academy over the past few years, and so with any art, one has to simply enjoy what we enjoy, and not worry about awards. I do think that nominations are good, as someone who saw ALL Best Picture nominees and it got me to see a really great surprise with Nickel Boys and also I’m Still Here. I would not have seen this otherwise.
Joker: Folie a Deux: I had heard all of the negative press about this movie and the almost universal condemnation of this sequel to the original Joker (2020) with Joaquin Phoenix in the Oscar winning performance, so I had avoided it. But recently on an airplane, it was on and I decided to watch. For me, I was scratching my head as to the whole concept for the film itself. From the “That’s Entertainment” song ringing in my ears, to the trial of Arthur Fleck at the television appearance in the original, and the pushing and pulling of Fleck versus The Joker as distinct persons living in the same body. One of my first observations was the weight loss from Phoenix and how utterly scary it was.

Next I thought, ‘what a tragedy to lose all that weight for this movie”. Just because you have added Lady Gaga to the cast, doesn’t mean that you should be making the film a musical, or even having musical numbers added. I can appreciate that she can sing, but it doesn’t move the story along really. Rather, for Phoenix, who is not a singer (not in a Russell Crowe (Les Miserables) or Pierce Brosnan (Mamma Mia) level of bad) and he did the biopic for Johnny Cash in Walk the Line, but this wasn’t good for him nor the character.

Then the trial aspect is explored with Fleck speaking with his lawyer, talking about multiple personality disorder and whether his troubled past made him not aware of the actions that he was taking. Enter Lady Gaga, Harley Quinn, as fellow inmate in Arkham, who seeks him out because of his actions on TV, as well as a made-for-TV movie that is referred to about the live air shooting. His fame and following is enticing for her. She disagrees with the legal defense of “I was not of sound mind when I did these acts” but thinks he needs to show his more chaotic personality, intent on tearing down the State from the outside. The singing continues with various numbers some of which are in dream states for Fleck. It is all rather confusing. Since her breakout performance in the re-make A Star is Born, Gaga has struggled with following it up with House of Gucci and this performance. Neither of which were compelling. Of course THIS Joker was never meant to be in the Christopher Nolan Batman universe. Other than being in the DC Universe, and having Harvey Dent as prosecutor, it really has nothing to do with it. The original was a turn on the Scorsese film The King of Comedy, right down to Robert Deniro, but this without the same underpinnings has lost its way, and floats in a no man’s land of obscurity never really finding out what the main message and the story should be. Maybe, those who are media sensations can also fall from grace just a quickly as they arrived. The mob doesn’t want realism, they want sensationalism. When you don’t deliver, you are dismissed. There are other stories that can can tell that tale better. In short, I agree with the negative reviews and I cannot recommend this.












